AI Beat

AnalysisTech

Google keeps its best model for the top plan, Claude learns spreadsheets, and a new music model edges past Suno

Gemini 4 Carbon is out, but in the Gemini app only Ultra subscribers get it. Claude picked up spreadsheets and whiteboards. Apple appears to be building a way to join Macs into one AI machine. And a music model from a small studio tied Suno at the top of a blind test.

Faders on a mixing desk, each pushed to a different level
Photo: Seungmin Yoon on Unsplash

Key points

  • Google released Gemini 4 Carbon, which it calls its strongest model. In the Gemini app it is for Google AI Ultra subscribers only; the €21.99 Pro plan gets Gemini 4 Argon. Developers pay $2 per million input tokens and $10 per million output, rising to $4 and $20 from 30 November.
  • None of the three big chatbots gives its very top model on the cheapest paid plan: Carbon needs Ultra, GPT-6 Astra needs ChatGPT Pro, and Claude Fable costs extra usage credits on Claude Pro.
  • Anthropic added Claude Sheets, Claude Whiteboards and Claude Data, and lets apps such as Adobe and Atlassian run inside Claude. It has not said which plans get them.
  • Apple is preparing Harbor, a Mac app that joins Macs over Thunderbolt 5 and pools their memory to run open AI models, according to a leak reported by 9to5Mac. Apple has not announced it.
  • ACE Music v1 took first place on Artificial Analysis's vocal music leaderboard with 1,160 points, 16 ahead of Suno v6. The margins overlap, so it is closer to a tie than a win.

Last week we watched agents break Linux at scale and Claude Fable 5.2 arrive. This week was about who gets what. Google shipped its strongest model and kept it for the most expensive plan. Claude moved further into office work. And in music, the leader of the past two years lost first place by a hair.

Carbon, for the few

Google released Gemini 4 Carbon on 10 November. It calls it “our strongest model”, built for long agent tasks, security work and science. It also spends more tokens to get there. For most coding and office work Google itself still points people to Gemini 4 Argon.

On Google’s own chart Carbon scores 59 on the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index, just above Claude Opus 5.5 at 58 and GPT-6 Astra at 57. It is not first on everything. On Google’s table Opus 5.5 still leads at operating a computer, and GPT-6 Astra at the hardest software tasks.

Who gets it is the real news. In the Gemini app, in Search’s AI Mode and in Google’s Antigravity coding tool, Carbon is rolling out to Google AI Ultra subscribers only, and only in some countries. Ultra starts at €99.99 a month in Europe, with a €219.99 tier for higher limits. The €21.99 Pro plan gets Argon. The free plan gets Flash-Lite.

Developers have an easier way in. Any paying API customer can use Carbon in Google AI Studio, at $2 per million input tokens and $10 per million output until 30 November, then $4 and $20.

What a cheap plan buys

So does anyone give you their best model for the price of a pizza a week? Not quite. Here is what the cheapest paid plan of each of the big three includes, from their pricing pages this week.

  • Google AI Pro, €21.99 a month: Gemini 4 Argon. Carbon needs Ultra.
  • ChatGPT Plus, €23 a month in Europe: GPT-6 with reasoning. GPT-6 Astra, OpenAI’s strongest, is listed under the Pro plan, from €103.
  • Claude Pro, $20 a month: Claude Opus 5.5 is included. Fable is not; Pro users pay for it with usage credits.

All three keep the top model for the top plan or charge extra for it. The difference is what sits one step below. On that, each lab says its second model is the right one for most daily work.

Why it matters to you: for writing, code and analysis, the second-best model on a $20 plan is usually enough. Pay for the top tier only when the hard, long tasks are your daily work, and try them on the API first, where you pay per use.

Claude learns spreadsheets

Anthropic added three kinds of shared work to Claude on 10 November. Claude Sheets builds spreadsheets with you, with formulas and several tabs. Claude Whiteboards is a board for laying out ideas in a meeting, which Claude can then sum up. Claude Data, the new name for Dashboards, connects to tools such as Snowflake and Salesforce and builds dashboards, data stories and short narrated videos.

Other companies’ apps can now run inside Claude too, so you can work in Adobe or Atlassian tools without switching tabs. Salesforce and Workday plug-ins are in beta. A meeting feature is “coming soon”.

Anthropic has not said which plans get what, or what it costs.

Macs that add up

Apple seems to be building an app called Harbor. It turns a Mac into a private server for open AI models and finds other Macs plugged in over Thunderbolt 5. Join two or more and their memory works as one pool, enough for models one machine could not hold. No terminal, no setup.

This comes from a leak, not from Apple. Aaron Perris, who often finds unreleased Apple software, posted the description on 10 November and 9to5Mac reported it. 9to5Mac adds that Harbor is in private preview under Apple’s Claris brand. There is no date, price or list of supported Macs yet.

Why it matters to you: if it ships, a small office could run a large open model on its own Macs, with nothing sent to a cloud. Thunderbolt 5 means recent Macs only.

A tie at the top of music

For two years Suno led the AI music charts. On Artificial Analysis’s vocal music leaderboard, built from blind votes by checked listeners, ACE Music v1 now sits first.

Best AI songs with vocals, by blind vote

Elo points. Bars start at 1,000, the score of MiniMax Music 3.0, which the leaderboard uses as its reference.

  1. ACE Music v11,160
  2. Suno v61,144
  3. Suno v6-mini1,132
  4. Mureka V9.51,101
  5. Mureka V91,063
  6. Google Lyria 3.51,050

Source: Artificial Analysis, AA-Music-Vocal v1.1, read 13 November 2026

The lead is 16 points. The margin of error on each score is about 20, so ACE and Suno are level within the noise. More votes will settle it.

ACE Music comes from TimeDomain, the US company behind the ACE Studio music app. The free plan gives 20 credits a day, enough for 10 songs, but you cannot download what you make, except with the older ACE-Step 1.5 model, which is free to use and download. Paid plans start at $7.90 a month and include downloads and commercial use. Free-plan songs stay personal: upgrading later does not make them commercial. Its terms also let the company train its models on what users upload since 1 November.

The pattern

The best models now cost real money, and the labs say so openly. The second tier is where most people live, and it keeps getting better. The surprises came from the edges: a music studio few had heard of, and Macs that may soon pool their memory.

Comments

What do you think? No account needed. Please be kind; comments that attack people are removed.

We store only your name and comment. See our privacy policy.

    Sources

    1. Google: Gemini 4 Carbon is now available (10 November 2026)
    2. Google: Gemini 4 Carbon, our next frontier model (28 October 2026)
    3. Google: Gemini subscriptions
    4. OpenAI: ChatGPT plans and pricing
    5. Anthropic: Claude pricing
    6. Anthropic: More ways to work with Claude: Sheets, Whiteboards, and Interactive Connectors (10 November 2026)
    7. 9to5Mac: Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI models easy (10 November 2026)
    8. Artificial Analysis: Music arena leaderboard, vocals
    9. ACE Music: Pricing
    10. ACE Music: Terms of Service (1 November 2026)